Erik and Lyle Menendez, two brothers convicted of murdering their dad and mom greater than three many years in the past, are one step nearer to being launched from jail.
The brothers are at the moment serving life in jail with out the potential of parole in California.
The Los Angeles County district lawyer formally really useful their resentencing in a court docket submitting on Friday, arguing for a lesser sentence for the pair. If accredited, the request would make the brothers eligible for parole.
Whereas it’s a vital improvement in a case that has gripped the nation, it’s one step on what might be a protracted highway.
And never everyone seems to be glad on the prospect of them probably regaining their freedom.
Resentencing request consists of particulars from time in jail
The 57-page court docket movement filed by the district lawyer’s workplace, obtained by BBC Information, features a timeline of the case, an argument for why the Menendez brothers ought to be resentenced and particulars of their time behind bars.
The submitting consists of glowing suggestions from jail officers and varied programmes the brothers launched behind bars that aimed to assist different inmates, together with those that had been victims of childhood trauma and disabled or aged inmates. It additionally consists of the academic levels each brothers obtained whereas serving their sentences.
All of this was carried out, the report notes, “with none expectation or hope of ever being launched”.
It additionally consists of the 30-year self-discipline information for each Erik Menendez and Lyle Menendez. Each brothers had been cited for possessing a cell phone in a cell they shared with different inmates.
Erik Menendez had a number of different violations, together with two fights, in 2011 and 1997.
It notes that Lyle Menendez was by no means cited for any fights and needed to be moved from the final inhabitants to the “particular wants” space of the jail in 1997 as a result of “he would not combat again when attacked”. He was cited twice for contraband – a lighter in 2013 and a brand new pair of Adidas sneakers in 1998 {that a} “feminine customer introduced him”.
“Whereas incarcerated, Erik and Lyle Menendez have remodeled and brought benefit of significant alternatives to mature, transfer past felony considering, repent, and change into a productive neighborhood members,” the submitting states, including they’re “able to reenter society”.
What occurs subsequent?
Friday’s submitting gives the premise for the district lawyer workplace’s argument that will likely be made earlier than a decide on why the brothers ought to be resentenced.
The subsequent step is to schedule a resentencing listening to, the place a decide will hear arguments for and in opposition to the change.
The workplace of George Gascón, the Los Angeles County district lawyer, is asking they be sentenced for homicide.
Beneath Californian regulation – primarily based on the age they had been on the time of the crimes – that might make them “eligible for parole instantly,” the district lawyer mentioned at a information convention Thursday.
His workplace says they hope to schedule the listening to someday within the subsequent 30-45 days and say it’s potential Lyle and Erik Menendez could attend the continuing.
The listening to is more likely to be contentious. Mr Gascón famous that this case has divided his workplace and members of his workers would possibly argue in opposition to him in court docket.
If the listening to ends in a decide approving the brand new sentence, consideration will shift to the California parole board.
The board will look at the case and whether or not the Menendez brothers are a menace to society if they’re launched.
Even when the board approves their launch, Governor Gavin Newsom may determine to halt proceedings.
What has the Menendez household been saying?
Earlier this month, greater than two dozen members of the Menendez household issued a public plea for Erik and Lyle to be launched 35 years after killing their dad and mom, Jose and Kitty Menendez.
These relations alleged the boys endured horrific sexual abuse by the hands of their father and will not be a menace to society.
Kitty Menendez’s sister, Joan Anderson VanderMolen, argued “the entire world wasn’t able to imagine that the boys might be raped, or that younger males might be victims of sexual violence”.
She mentioned that now “we all know higher” and “a jury in the present day would by no means ship such a harsh sentence”.
However the household is not in whole settlement.
A lawyer for Kitty Menendez’s brother, Milton Andersen, referred to as the brothers “cold-blooded” and mentioned their “actions shattered their household and left a path of grief that has continued for many years.”
“Jose was shot six occasions, and Kitty was shot ten occasions, together with a shot to her face after Erik reloaded.”
Mr Andersen believes his nephews ought to keep in jail for his or her “heinous act”, based on his lawyer, Kathy Cady.
Why is that this occurring – 35 years after the killings?
Neama Rahmani, a felony defence lawyer and former federal prosecutor, advised the BBC {that a} “good storm of PR and politics” has led to the Menendez brothers having an actual shot at freedom.
He famous the current consideration the case has gotten from celebrities, a Netflix drama and docuseries on the case, and an “embattled” district lawyer vying to stay in workplace.
“You are by no means going to see one other case like this. It is a unicorn.”
The Menendez brothers filed a movement in Could 2023 detailing new proof of their case and requesting their convictions be vacated.
Mr Gascón mentioned his workplace had been reviewing the case for greater than a 12 months, however he mentioned he made the choice to suggest their resentencing Thursday, solely an hour earlier than holding a extremely publicised information convention on the landmark case.
The choice was introduced 12 days earlier than election day, wherein Mr Gascón is operating for re-election as Los Angeles county district lawyer and is down by 30 factors in some polls. He has denied his announcement was political and mentioned it was a long-time coming.
The choice additionally got here amid renewed consideration within the case spurred by a new Netflix drama, Monsters: The Lyle and Erik Menendez Story in addition to the discharge of docudrama, The Menendez Brothers.
The collection launched the case to a brand new technology and garnered consideration from celebrities – together with Kim Kardashian and Rosie O’Donnell – who referred to as for the brothers to be launched.
Why did the Menendez brothers kill their dad and mom?
Motive has lengthy been on the coronary heart of this case.
Prosecutors painted the brothers as spoiled wealthy children, who killed their rich dad and mom of their Beverly Hills mansion so they may entry their $14m (£10.7m) fortune.
They argued the duo methodically purchased shotguns and fatally shot their dad and mom a complete of 13 occasions because the couple watched TV. They then went playing, to events and on purchasing sprees, shopping for issues like Rolex watches.
It was in the end a confession to a psychologist that helped result in their arrest when the girlfriend of their physician audiotaped their admission and reported it to authorities.
The brothers in the end admitted to the killings – however argued they acted out of self-defence after years of emotional, bodily and sexual abuse.
They advised the court docket they feared their dad and mom would kill them in the event that they didn’t act first. Lyle and Erik testified they confronted their dad and mom in regards to the sexual abuse and issues had change into combative of their family they usually believed their dad and mom had been planning to kill them.
Members of the family testified in regards to the abuse they witnessed – however none mentioned they noticed sexual abuse first-hand.
The twists and turns within the story made it notorious and even 35 years later it continues to be the catalyst for brand spanking new documentaries and movies.
