On Monday, Stack Overflow and OpenAI introduced a brand new API partnership that can combine Stack Overflow’s technical content material with OpenAI’s ChatGPT AI assistant. Nonetheless, the deal has sparked controversy amongst Stack Overflow’s consumer neighborhood, with many expressing anger and protest over using their contributed content material to assist and prepare AI fashions.
“I hate this. I am simply going to delete/deface my solutions one after the other,” wrote one consumer on sister website Stack Change. “I do not care if that is in opposition to your foolish insurance policies, as a result of as this announcement reveals, your insurance policies can change at a whim with out prior session of your stakeholders. You do not care about your customers, I do not care about you.”
Stack Overflow is a well-liked question-and-answer website for software program builders that enables customers to ask and reply technical questions associated to coding. The location has a big neighborhood of builders who contribute data and experience to assist others resolve programming issues. Over the previous decade, Stack Overflow has change into a closely utilized useful resource for a lot of builders searching for options to widespread coding challenges.
Below the introduced partnership, OpenAI will make the most of Stack Overflow’s OverflowAPI product to enhance its AI fashions utilizing content material from the Stack Overflow neighborhood—formally incorporating data that many imagine it had beforehand scraped with out a license. OpenAI may even “floor validated technical data from Stack Overflow straight into ChatGPT, giving customers quick access to trusted, attributed, correct, and extremely technical data and code backed by the thousands and thousands of builders which have contributed to the Stack Overflow platform for 15 years,” in line with Stack Overflow.
In return, OpenAI plans to offer attribution to the Stack Overflow neighborhood inside ChatGPT, however how the corporate will do this precisely is unclear. Stack Overflow may even use OpenAI know-how in its improvement of OverflowAI, an AI mannequin introduced in July 2023 that makes use of an LLM to offer solutions to developer questions.
Whereas the businesses tout the collaboration’s advantages, many Stack Overflow customers have expressed their displeasure with the deal. That is very true contemplating that till very just lately, Stack Overflow appeared to take a destructive stance towards generative AI typically, banning solutions written utilizing ChatGPT. It was additionally broadly reported final 12 months that ChatGPT’s recognition had severely diminished Stack Overflow’s visitors, although the corporate appeared to later refute that, claiming defective evaluation by outsiders.
For the reason that announcement, some customers have tried to change or delete their Stack Overflow posts in protest, arguing that the transfer steals the labor of those that contributed to the platform with out a method to choose out. In retaliation, Stack Overflow employees have reportedly been banning these customers whereas erasing or reverting the protest posts. On Monday, a Stack Overflow consumer named Ben took to Mastodon to share his expertise of getting suspended after posting a protest message:
Stack Overflow introduced that they’re partnering with OpenAI, so I attempted to delete my highest-rated solutions.
Stack Overflow doesn’t allow you to delete questions which have accepted solutions and plenty of upvotes as a result of it could take away data from the neighborhood.
So as an alternative I modified my highest-rated solutions to a protest message.
Inside an hour mods had modified the questions again and suspended my account for 7 days.
Stack Overflow moderators have said that after posts are made, they change into “a part of the collective efforts” of different contributors and will solely be eliminated underneath extraordinary circumstances, in line with The Verge. Stack Overflow’s phrases of service additionally state that customers can not revoke permission for Stack Overflow to make use of their contributed content material.
Whereas Stack Overflow owns consumer posts, the positioning makes use of a Artistic Commons 4.0 license that requires attribution. We’ll see if the ChatGPT integrations, which haven’t rolled out but, will honor that license to the satisfaction of disgruntled Stack Overflow customers. For now, the battle continues.
