SPECIAL REPORT – Within the final days of 2024, The Cipher Temporary turned to our community of specialists – who spend a lot of their time wanting on the dangers and threats going through the U.S. and the remainder of world – and requested them a unique query, extra in keeping with the vacation season: What offers them hope?
Whereas our focus – and theirs – is essentially on battle, cyberattacks, gray-zone techniques, the “Axis of Authoritarians,” and so forth, right here we requested the specialists to replicate on one particular query: What, if something, on the nationwide/world safety panorama offers you cause for hope?
Their solutions coated a variety of points and components of the world – from the spirit of innovation to advances in AI to the Center East (sure, “hope” and “Center East” have been joined in multiple reply). Some supplied a number of paragraphs; others a single sentence; one respondent – the previous Director of Nationwide Intelligence James Clapper – gave a two-word (and never so hopeful) reply.
Taken collectively, they’ve given us a lot to consider, as 2024 attracts to an in depth and the brand new 12 months beckons. We hope they add notes of hope to your vacation season as properly.
Common David Petraeus (Ret.)
Common David Petraeus served greater than 37 years within the U.S. navy with six consecutive instructions, 5 of which have been fight, together with command of the Multi-Nationwide Drive-Iraq in the course of the Surge, U.S. Central Command, and Coalition and U.S. Forces in Afghanistan. He’s a accomplice within the KKR world funding agency and chairs the agency’s world institute.
Gen. Petraeus: The tempo of America’s technological innovativeness, the emergence of vastly spectacular entrepreneurial younger leaders on this nation, and the fundamental qualities and attributes of the U.S. financial ecosystem are all sources of monumental hope, regardless of the return of geopolitics with a vengeance and the sheer variety of complexities within the challenges world wide.
Common Frank McKenzie (Ret.)
Gen. McKenzie (Ret.) is Govt Director of the College of South Florida’s World and Nationwide Safety Institute. In July 2022, he additionally grew to become the Govt Director of the Florida Middle for Cybersecurity, also referred to as Cyber Florida. He’s the previous Commander, United States Central Command. Gen. McKenzie was commissioned into the Marine Corps and skilled as an infantry officer.
Gen. McKenzie: There may be hope within the Center East, and what has occurred to Iran. The decapitation of Lebanese Hezbollah has eliminated Iran’s strategic hedge towards Israel. The failure of two Iranian missile and drone assaults on Israel laid naked their offensive inadequacies earlier than the world. The Israeli response has highlighted the growing technological hole between Israel and Iran. The sudden demise of Bashar al-Assad’s Syria is a becoming finish to what has confirmed to be a disastrous 12 months for Iran. Each foundational component of Iranian safety coverage has been examined — and located wanting.
John McLaughlin
John McLaughlin is the Distinguished Practitioner in Residence on the Johns Hopkins Faculty of Superior Worldwide Research (SAIS). He served as each Appearing Director and Deputy Director of the Central Intelligence Company. McLaughlin served as a U.S. Military Officer within the Sixties, with service in Vietnam.
McLaughlin: There may be maybe a ray of hope within the weakening of Iran and the weakening of Hezbollah on account of their conflicts with Israel. Neither is in a really sturdy place to proceed creating instability within the Center East. The collapse of the Assad authorities in Syria is expounded to this and could also be a supply of hope or despair, relying on what the brand new authorities chooses to do and with whom it chooses to ally.
Nick Fishwick
Nick Fishwick CMG retired after almost thirty years within the British International Service. His postings included Lagos, Istanbul and Kabul. His duties in London included director of safety and, after coming back from Afghanistan in 2007, he served as director for counter-terrorism. His ultimate position was as director common for worldwide operations.
Fishwick: 2024 was a brutal 12 months, however I discovered some comfort: first, the strategic downgrading of the capabilities of Hamas and Hezbollah should be good for regional safety within the Center East, as a result of they need to imply a decisive setback for Iran’s regional ambitions. Secondly, a 12 months in the past observers anxious about elections in 2024 and whether or not democracy was beneath risk, not least within the U.S. So it was one thing that elections on either side of the pond labored with outcomes that have been accepted and most of the people realizing that in the event that they didn’t just like the outcomes – properly, that’s democracy. On the identical time, continued meddling in inside politics by malicious actors – have a look at Georgia and Romania – have to be countered aggressively.
Extra broadly it appears to me that the perfect playing cards – technological, financial, political – are nonetheless in western arms. We should always trust in our values – free speech, democracy, pluralism – as a result of different nations undergo for his or her absence. We’d like leaders who’ve an appreciation of how energy works within the fashionable world and who will use it in defence of these values. We’d like western governments who will use this energy a bit extra assertively, slightly than apologize for it.
Linda Weissgold
Linda Weissgold spent 37-years at CIA. Earlier than the 9/11 terrorist assaults, she was an analyst and chief of analytic packages targeted on the Center East. She served as head of the CIA’s Workplace of Terrorism Evaluation and helped to establish Usama Bin Laden’s location and the rise of ISIS. For greater than two years, she served as President George W. Bush’s intelligence briefer.
Weissgold: Whereas there’s prone to be a rising hole within the years forward between what individuals demand and what governments can ship, it’s laborious to not be optimistic about our future when interacting with the American non-public sector and proficient college students. The entrepreneurial spirit is alive and properly, and if we, as a society, demand the sources, I’ve little doubt that the non-public sector will reply positively and shortly. I’m already seeing indicators that the expertise is evolving to supply extra transparency for many who wish to discover different views, learn authentic sources, and guarantee that pictures haven’t been doctored. I even have simply accomplished my first semester instructing at Texas A&M’s Bush Faculty of Authorities and Public Service in Washington, DC. I can’t assist however be impressed by a brand new era thinking about answering the decision for public service to make the world a greater and safer place.
Ralph Goff
Ralph Goff is a 35-year veteran of the CIA the place he was a 6-time Chief of Station with in depth service in Europe, the Center East, and Central and South Asia together with a number of battle zones. He served as Chief of Operations for Europe and Eurasia. Goff additionally served as Chief of CIA’s Nationwide Assets Division, working extensively with “C Suite” degree US non-public sector executives within the monetary, banking, and safety sectors.
Goff: The standard of younger-generation members in each the U.S. intelligence group and the U.S. Particular Army Operations Command. They’re tech-savvy – way more so than my era will ever be. They’re intellectually curious however way more skeptical than was my era. This skepticism means they have an inclination to query authority – generally possibly an excessive amount of. Nonetheless, when their older era leaders earn their belief – and their belief is earned, not merely given – they’re able to following orders and finishing up essentially the most difficult duties. I’m very optimistic concerning the subsequent era of younger leaders each in authorities and the navy in addition to within the non-public sector.
Ambassador Joseph DeTrani
Ambassador Joseph DeTrani served because the U.S. Consultant to the Korea Vitality Improvement Group (KEDO), in addition to former CIA director of East Asia Operations. He additionally served as Affiliate Director of Nationwide Intelligence and Mission Supervisor for North Korea, was the Particular Envoy for the Six-Celebration Talks with North Korea, and served because the Director of the Nationwide Counter Proliferation Middle, ODNI. He at present serves on the Board of Managers at Sandia Nationwide Laboratories.
Amb. DeTrani: That China and the U.S. understand that there are a myriad of world safety points on which we are able to and will collaborate: Pandemics, local weather change, drug trafficking, nuclear proliferation, worldwide organized crime, and worldwide terrorism.
In the meantime, China’s Xi Jinping will understand {that a} navy transfer towards Taiwan will not be in China’s curiosity, so long as Taiwan doesn’t declare independence. And whereas Xi Jinping’s plan to make China the preeminent world energy by 2049 will persist in propaganda, in actuality, China will face large financial and home political points that can show troublesome to handle, making certain that China won’t ever be the preeminent world energy. This, whereas the U.S. financial system continues to develop, and folks in additional nations, together with China, understand that dictatorships/autocracies don’t profit the individuals or the nation. International locations will aspire to be democratic, regardless of brutal efforts by dictators and despots to cease them.
Paula Doyle
Paula Doyle served as Assistant Deputy Director for Operations at CIA, the place she oversaw worldwide HUMINT operations and actions that required the usage of air, land, maritime, space-based and cyber applied sciences. She was the Deputy Nationwide Counterintelligence Govt from 2012-2014, the place she oversaw the official US Injury Evaluation ensuing from Non-public Manning’s 2010 unauthorized disclosures to Wikileaks and led the IC’s in depth evaluation of Edward Snowden’s unauthorized disclosures and defection to Russia. She led three CIA stations in Europe, the Levant, and Asia.
Doyle: Within the Center East, the brand new administration can set bolder insurance policies. First, shortly finish the violence in Israel, Lebanon and Gaza, and rush in large deliveries of “made within the USA” meals, water, blankets, and shelter in order that on a regular basis individuals affected by the wars can go house — visibly seeing a proactive position by the US. Second, mount a devoted messaging marketing campaign that exposes Tehran’s lengthy observe report of failure wherever it has gone — e.g., persistent instability, wholesale destruction, human struggling, and countless wars affecting thousands and thousands of on a regular basis households. U.S. messaging ought to affiliate Iran with a future that guarantees instability, destruction, and struggling. The messages ought to encourage the individuals of the area to make higher selections. Third, the U.S. ought to establish elected leaders in Lebanon and Iraq who’re keen guilty Iran, Lebanese Hezbollah, and Kata’ib Hezbollah for inflicting such profound hurt to their individuals. As these three targets fall into place, the U.S. ought to decide to serving to trusted Iraqi and Lebanese actors confront inside corruption and terrorism, rebuild wrecked buildings and infrastructures, and restore market-based financial practices.
In 2024, Ukraine conquered part of Russian territory and broken and/or destroyed Russian munitions depots and air airfields in ways in which ought to give Kyiv a stronger place from which to barter the return of some or all of japanese Ukraine and Crimea. If either side ought to agree to barter, Moscow and Kyiv might arrive at a ceasefire association and a inexperienced zone demarcation that UN peacekeepers might monitor and implement. Two fashionable ceasefire preparations come to thoughts as attainable fashions: Kosovo and Cyprus. Neither ceasefire settlement has been truthful to hundreds of separated households, misplaced properties and companies, and empty chairs at numerous tables; each ceasefires, nevertheless, have resulted in many years of relative peace and prosperity between opponents.
If sovereignty stays the coin of the civilized society’s realm, Russia will withdraw; nations holding frozen or ceased Russian belongings must be allowed to realign them to the reconstruction of Ukraine. That is extra hope than chance.
If Russia will get to maintain one inch of Ukraine, nevertheless, (because it has completed vis-a-vis South Ossetia since 2008), sovereignty will erode and change into an appeasement instrument that can function a mannequin for China to change into extra aggressive with Taiwan and its ambitions within the South China Sea. Appeasement is a coverage born of worry, fatigue, weak point, and doubt. It’s un-American. Sovereignty should prevail. Slava Ukraini.
Nick Thompson
Nick Thompson is a former CIA Paramilitary Case Officer and Naval Particular Warfare Improvement Group operator. With over 20 years of expertise within the nationwide safety house, Nick has performed numerous clandestine operations and fight deployments with a major focus within the Center East and Asia. He has commonly navigated and led international intelligence assortment and covert motion initiatives by constructing networks with a various vary of stakeholders. He now works in Washington D.C. at Anduril Industries, a number one protection expertise firm, searching for to convey innovative functionality to intelligence and protection professionals alike.
Thompson: Continued, swift and enhanced multilateral cooperation. Finland and Sweden, welcome to NATO. The AUKUS (the U.S., UK, and Australia) safety partnership continues to progress and can pave the way in which for formidable and floor breaking expertise to achieve finish customers at velocity. The landmark Abraham Accords between Israel, the UAE and Bahrain have grown to incorporate Morocco and Sudan. Hopefully Saudi Arabia is subsequent to hitch. South Korea and Japan, two strategically essential nations, are shifting collectively cautiously and collaborating on intelligence and protection once more. Whereas these alliances tackle terrorism, promote financial stability and progress, and plenty of different issues, their most essential position is sending a message of deterrence to our most succesful adversaries.
Ellen McCarthy
Ellen McCarthy is Chairwoman and CEO of the Belief in Media Cooperative. She has over three many years of nationwide safety service in quite a lot of management roles that span quite a few intelligence organizations, most lately serving because the Assistant Secretary of State for the Bureau of Intelligence and Analysis. She’s at present a senior fellow on the Belfer Middle at Harvard College.
McCarthy: Heading into 2025 there are numerous causes to be hopeful. The identical developments in AI that problem the knowledge ecosystem are additionally driving breakthroughs in healthcare, science, schooling and protection. Improvements in AI, quantum computing and cyber safety will bolster nationwide safety capabilities, bettering risk detection and resolution making precision.
Lt. Gen. James R. Clapper (Ret.)
Lt. Gen. James Clapper served from 2010 – 2017 because the Director of Nationwide Intelligence. He served in two administrations because the Underneath Secretary of Protection for Intelligence and directed the Nationwide Imagery and Mapping Company (NIMA), reworking it into the Nationwide Geospatial-Intelligence Company (NGA).
Lt. Gen. Clapper: Not a lot.
Emile Nakhleh
Dr. Emile Nakhleh is a retired Senior Intelligence Service Officer, a founding director of the CIA’s Political Islam Strategic Evaluation Program and the World and the Nationwide Safety Coverage Institute on the College of New Mexico. Since retiring from the federal government, Nakhleh has consulted on nationwide safety points, notably Islamic radicalization, terrorism, and the Arab states of the Center East. He’s a life member of the Council on International Relations.
Nakhleh: On the threat of sounding pollyannish, I’d flag a number of hopeful potentialities:
Donald Trump’s proclivities, and attainable insurance policies, to finish regional conflicts, notably between Russia and Ukraine and between Israel and its neighbors; a attainable path towards a two-state resolution in Israel/Palestine; an surprising rapprochement between Israel and Iran and concomitantly between Iran and its Gulf Arab neighbors; and a extra steady interval of world commerce regardless of Trump’s risk of tariffs.
Any of the above optimistic eventualities can be undermined by the emergence of a number of surprising and doubtlessly disruptive wild playing cards. These might embody: Coordinated rogue use of AI and cyber warfare by non-state actors, which the prevailing world order could be unable to fight or neutralize; ascendant BRICS and different worldwide groupings that would undercut America’s affect and financial dominance regionally and globally. Trump’s risk to impose 100% tariffs on BRICS member states can be ineffective and definitely dangerous to world order and worldwide commerce and banking; Israel and Iran (and their proxies) might reject all makes an attempt at rapprochement and as a substitute careen towards all-out regional battle.
Learn extra expert-driven nationwide safety insights, perspective and evaluation in The Cipher Temporary.
